Kompany v Smalling: no contest

When you spent most of your playing days competing for headers, you tend to recognize little things that suggest one player wanted to get a head on the ball considerably more than the other.

Vincent Kompany wanted to win that header he scored on today to give Man City a 1-0 win and potentially their first English Premier League title. Chris Smalling, through his decision to pull off of Kompany to the near post unnecessarily early, clearly did not. Watch the video after the jump:

The important part is from 36 second to 38 seconds. Two seconds. That’s all it takes to win and lose a header, a game and perhaps a league title.

Kompany is a beast. I think he’s made a case this season for the title of best centre back in the league. He’s the sort of guy no one looks forward to jumping against because he is big, strong and you know he is going to compete for the ball in the air and not give it a half hearted lunge that speaks more of self preservation than glory. And let’s be honest, contesting headers off corners is not for the feint of heart at this level. Once you’ve been smacked by a few elbows or had some head to head contact, more than a few start pulling the sort of marking job that Smalling did on Kompany today.

There is no logical reason to pull off of Kompany as early as Smalling did. He pulls off so far that he ends up going around another pairing of United and City players (Rio and Lescott?) contesting the corner and at one point is a good three steps from the City centre back. It’s far too early for him to have seen the ball played to the near post space os there’s no valid reason for him to come into that space. All he’s doing is allowing Kompany to get clear and not have to jump with a defender mauling him for the ball. A mauling that Smalling seemingly is not interested in giving him.

So as the ball comes over it is left for Smalling to jump backwards to try to reach it while Kompany can jump up and into the ball. When their feet leave the ground there is still two yards separating them. You cannot give Vincent Kompany that much room that close in on a corner kick. He has to be jostled and to jostle you have to be inches not yards away. It’s no contest and as the commentator on the video says, “Smalling knows he’s been caught out. Scholes knows. Rooney know.” To experienced players this reeks of either amateur hour defending or someone who has decided they’re just not up for competing for cross balls with someone like Kompany, so they over-commit to the near post to make it look like they’re trying to get an early jump to a ball played to that space. But when the jump precedes any indication of the ball actually being delivered there, it becomes alarmingly obvious that the real intent was to bugger off on the responsibility to jump with the player on the other team who is the biggest threat on corners because you didn’t fancy your odds or you didn’t fancy a nasty collision.

Games can turn on the smallest of incidents. City were the better team today but chances for both teams were few and far between so this ended up being the difference. Smalling will no doubt hear about this from Sir Alex and from some teammates.

This entry was posted in Coaching, Video highlights and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Kompany v Smalling: no contest

  1. cutleron says:

    At the ages where this starts to matter to win youth games, U15 and up, the single most important thing a coach can do is to designate players on the field who will remind teammates forcefully that winning headers prevents goals and that they need to want to head the ball and must pick up the flight of the ball early. I imagine, Gregor, you were that guy.
    We can train kids all we want to head the ball properly but without a timely reminder, they won’t even make an attempt to win a defensive header.

    • Gregor says:

      I’d agree that U15 is about the right edge to start reinforcing that in the end we play games to see who wins and the attributes of a top soccer player include the tangibles and intangibles related to the pursuit of winning. Fair to say I was that guy. Wasn’t a terribly physical centre back but I leveraged an ability to win headers (more through timing and a half decent leap) and it got me about as far as I could really ever hope to go.

      I remember doing the theory part of my B National and in part of it I had to organize my team on a dry erase board for various scenarios. One was defending a corner kick and I told the instructors (Ray Clark and Dave Benning) that I’d put my toughest, most resolute ball winner in the near post space because winning driven balls to the near post is a tough gig and a crucial task. They agreed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s