Analysis: Goals in the United v Arsenal game (Updated due to video being taken down by YouTube)

UPDATE: YouTube emailed to say they have taken the video down due to a copyright infringement claim by the FA Premier League. I’ve filed an appeal but having never been in this situation before I don’t know if I’ll ever hear back from them. Bit bummed as it took me about five hours to do that video and the YouTube annotation system is really well set up for this sort of thing. For the record, I understand the need for the FA to control their copyrighted material. It has tremendous financial value and they have stakeholders that are entitled to any revenues that flow from their intellectual property. I just want to point out that this blog has no advertising on it and does not derive revenue from any other source and my YouTube account is not set up on their AdSense program so there is no revenue flowing from YouTube to me although it could be argued that YouTube could derive revenues from ads they choose to run on the page showing videos I have put up. I still believe that if the video is hosted on an American website (YouTube) and there are laws allowing for educational use of copyright material, my use of Premier League highlights should fall under that category.

 

It was a remarkable game. 8-2. Maybe even a watershed moment for clubs moving in different directions.

A ten goal blowout between two teams that are ostensibly among the league’s best. United, having been embarrassed by Barcelona just three months ago in the Champions League Final fielded a very different lineup against Arsenal. Not only is Van Der Sar replaced in goal by newcomer De Gea, but Evra was the only defender (mainly due to injuries) that started both games. United’s entire midfield was changed to as they shifted from Carrick, Valencia, Giggs and Park to Cleverley, Young, Anderson and Nani. Rooney kept his spot up front but his partner on the day was Danny Welbeck rather than Chicharito.

In other words, nine new faces against Arsenal from the squad that was taken apart by Barcelona at the end of May.

Analysis video here

Of course Arsenal were different from their last game of the season as well. Szczęsny was still in goal but Djourou was the only defender on the field when they faced Fulham in the last game of the season who also lined up against United. Aaron Ramsey and Robin Van Persie round out the only other Arsenal holdovers from last May to today’s starting eleven.

So while they both had change in common, United’s was by choice while Arsenal’s was out of desperation with the recent sales of Fabregas and Nasri and a long list of injuries.

Most were predicting a United win but few will have put money down on a six goal spread.

What those who watched got was a goal feast and all goal feasts deserve special attention so I thought I’d take a long, hard look at them all to see how they evolved and who (Jenkinson) was to blame for the lion’s share.

A pet peeve of mine, as per the bit on functional play I posted awhile ago, is conceding goals from poor clearances that allow a second chance at goal. No fewer than four of the ten goals came about through these means in this game. Evra was the worst offender on Walcott’s goal but it’s shocking how many goals, even at the highest level, come through poor clearances. Even more shocking is that all four of the offending goals in this game were uncontested clearances.

Another root cause of the goals was fouls committed as a result of defenders getting caught wrong side and having to barge, in varying degrees, attackers from behind. Two goals came via such fouls and Jenkinson earned a second yellow reducing Arsenal to ten men through the same sort of offence.

I’ve heavily annotated a decent quality video of the extended highlights with my thoughts on the positive things that were done to create goals and the mistakes made defensively that allowed some of them.

The video has already been tagged by YouTube as subject to a content claim so have a look here before it gets taken down (I have a dispute in to YouTube on the basis of it being educational, which is considered Fair Use and generally allows for use of copyrighted content)

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Video highlights and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Analysis: Goals in the United v Arsenal game (Updated due to video being taken down by YouTube)

  1. K says:

    What site do you download full games from? Would love access to that as I don’t have TV packages which include Serie A, Bundesliga, or La Liga not to mention SPL – that being said, St. Mirren have an excellent striker, named Hasselbaink….young, small, extremely athletic. Look out for him.??

    • Gregor says:

      I used this one: http://pakmans-footy-blog.blogspot.com/

      He’s already got the first half of the Barcelona v Villareal game that just ended an hour ago up. Problem is that each half is generally divided into two downloads and they’re on things like Hotfile that put restrictions on how many downloads per hour and how many downloads you can do at a time (ie. one) unless you buy a premium membership. It works though.

  2. DJones says:

    That’s disappointing. You did a great job on it Gregor.

    I was planning on sending it to my players to watch and analyze.

    Boo to the FA Premier League. I even tried to download it on my Mac but it wouldn’t let me.

    Could you put it on Daily Motion instead? They take longer to take videos down.

    • Gregor says:

      Thanks Danny, I appreciate that.

      The problem is that all the annotations were done on YouTube using their tools so while I still have the actual video, I lost all the notes I’d superimposed on it. When I saw there was a claim on it, I used several tools on pwnyoutube.com to try to download it but it would only download the video and none of the notes I’d added. Pisses me off because not only was it a lot of time but I did think that there were lots of good examples that would be really relevant to coaches. I should’ve just done it in iMovie and upgraded my WordPress account to allow video uploads on their platform.

  3. Larry says:

    That’s to bad about the youtube issue Gregor. It would have been interesting to watch your video analysis. I recorded the game, not realizing at the time that the outcome would be so shocking. I watched it with my 13yr old daughter and she pointed out out many of the errors you mentioned.
    There are numerous file sharing type site out there such as Box and others, but most are more collaborative versus broadcast or push. Sounds like the upgraded WordPress would be the best approach.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s