Stupid player or officious official?

Rangers are playing Malmo in the second leg of the Champions League Qualifying Third Round tie. They lost 1-0 at home so they need a win in Sweden to get to the filthy lucre that is the Champions League group stages.

Steven Whittaker is a Scottish international playing for Rangers. Around the 18th minute, with the score still 0-0, he gets fouled. It’s a bad foul in that it’s obvious and there is some intent to hurt, if not injure, him. His reaction though is absurd. Have a look:

This is an experienced player. His team desperately need a win away from home to get to the Champions League group stages. Not only is it financial heaven for clubs, it’s nirvana for players who ply their trade in less glamourous leagues like the Scottish Premier (away to Aberdeen anyone?) and he goes out of his way to piss it away for himself and his teammates.

Now the flip side of this is this is a great example of how far the tables have turned and how the reaction to bad fouls is now punished far more severely than the original foul. The best example of this is David Beckham’s red card in the 1998 World Cup against Argentina. He’s on the ground and, almost casually, throws his leg up to tap an Argentinian after having been fouled. An incredibly weak red card that he was vilified for for years.

For reference sake:

(Note how Diego Simeone drags his foot along Beckham’s ribs as he back peddles…he got a yellow)

Back to Whittaker, look at the foul. That’s a professional foul, full of intent. He’s saved from injury primarily due to the fact that neither of them are moving at much more than a crawl when it happens but it’s a foul. So is picking up the ball and hulking it at the person who fouled you. But is it really a red card? Is that the standard now for ejections? For me the original foul is far more egregious and opens the door to players to wind up opponents with fouls if they think they’re dealing with a hot head who will react. They may get a yellow for the original offense but their opponent will get a red and you’ll get to play against ten men the rest of the game.

The second half is just starting as I write this and Rangers are actually up 1-0 so Whittaker may be saved a public flogging at Ibrox when they get home if they manage to squeak through. The odds are still against though as they are looking at needing another goal in the second half and they’ll be trying to do it down a man thanks to a combination of stupidity from Whittaker and the FIFA-encouraged officiousness of game officials.

This entry was posted in Making the game better and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Stupid player or officious official?

  1. Kurt says:

    Stupid player. Stupid official.

  2. Gregor says:

    It wasn’t an isolated incident apparently. Two more red cards in the game. Malmo scored with 11 to go to put Rangers out of the Champions League and into (further) debt no doubt.

  3. footyfanatic says:

    Malmo player should have had a red card. Had that play been at a quicker pace, he could have broken his leg. Throwing a ball is stupid, but no more than a yellow. I guess we can start red carding players when their free kicks hit the wall. 😉

    • Gregor says:

      Agreed. If the reaction was a red, I’d also have a given a red for the foul. But the common sense solution would have been a yellow for each of them.

  4. Stephen Burns says:

    Gregor, the initial foul was not the tackle on Whittaker. The whistle had already blown for a foul against Rangers on the touchline. Look at the ref’s arm and the Malmo playing who is lying on the side after he was chopped down. This is the only way Rangers know how to play nowadays but they get away with it in Scotland. In Europe, it’s not as simple. The play was blown dead already when the Malmo player ‘tackled’ Whittaker. According to the laws of the game ,Whittaker throwing the ball at the players head/neck/shoulders is viewed as VIOLENT CONDUCT, which is an automatic red card. I’m not just saying this because it is a Rangers player but if you throw a ball at a player like that it should be a sending off. Either way, Europe is a better place with Rangers. 🙂

  5. Stephen Burns says:

    🙂 🙂 Great observation, Gregor. I’m at peace now with my dislike for them and only want them to do well in all their competitions. Yah, right. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s